Posts Tagged → humane
Ravin xbow post script
As I write this, the 2026 Pennsylvania deer archery-only hunting season is coming to an end. Tomorrow. Tomorrow also marks the arrivals in bear camp, mostly across the northern tier, which is traditional bear hunting country.
“Bear camp” is our PA way of saying hunters gathering together to hunt black bears, in an old or new-er cabin or shack or modern home, to do bear drives and coordinated hunts among groups of people. We have such a gathering ourselves, and in fact tomorrow marks 25 years of us meeting here to hunt bears together. “Us” being a core group of ever-greyer family men, now joined by a group of were-younger family men, some of whom are turning a touch of grey themselves.
So, if you did not yet arrow the buck of your dreams over the past seven weeks of archery season, or arrow even your third-place expectation buck, tomorrow, Friday, is your last chance, until deer rifle season, the Saturday after Thanksgiving. But by then, the deer rut will be winding down, and the bucks will not be making the kinds of mistakes they have made the past few weeks. They will be much harder to find and kill.
For us bear hunters, we now shift into bear hunting mode. Make sure our rifles are sighted in, functioning, etc, our hunter orange fits and zips, our radios work, knives are sharp, hunting boots are waterproofed, etc. Bear hunting by “gang” or “party” or drive up in the mountains is strenuous, and kit has to be polished. Ready.
Bear drives are also dangerous. Last year a guy was shot and killed by a fellow driver as a bear ran between them. This is why safety is Job #1, and why drive lines have to be disciplined and tight. The margin for error is slim, the cost of error is astronomical. We use radios instead of the traditional “hey-o” shouts, because we keep better communication this way, and we do not spook the critters as much. Un-spooked critters provide better shots, because they are sneaking, not fleeing.
So good luck to the last-minute deer archers and to the early bird bear hunters tomorrow. Be safe, have fun, celebrate time together with people you love and admire. These moments together are rare and precious. These moments together in the chase are a superior use of time than playing the latest video game or hanging out at a bar. Humans have gathered around the campfire in pursuit of wild animals since the dawn of our species. It is as natural and as healthy and as organically human an activity as can be had. And deer meat is as organic a food as can be had.
Now, the post script on my own deer archery season: Today I arrowed the third doe of the season. She came in at a smart angle, cagey and hidden in brush, to inspect the estrous doe pee and doe decoy combination invading her territory. Because I was well concealed, and pretty well de-stinkified, she did not know of my presence until it was too late.
At eight yards and broadside, her head suddenly snapped right and she stared me in the face. The visible moment of “oh crap” in her eyes was sad, not humorous, but the fact is, we have way too many deer eating up our native forests. And so even as her eyes widened in horror at the human oh-so-close, she was already a dead doe running. The arrow whipped through her lungs faster than my eyes could follow, and within a fraction of a second she was running across my field of vision, a hole above her shoulder already leaking precious hydraulic fluid. I found her a hundred yards (!) down the logging trail, stone cold dead.
Removing over-abundant does from the landscape results in much healthier, bigger bucks, as well as a more diverse and healthier native forest. Feed/food is limited in the hills, mostly twigs and acorns, and if too many mouths are competing for a limited resource, everyone suffers. The fewer mouths, the better for both the deer herd and the native plants that are over-browsed by over-abundant deer.
Below are some photos that require the squeamish to finish reading here. The purpose of the one gory picture is not to crudely revel in the power, ferocity, or terrible brutality of the weapon, or to mock these animals’ deaths. Rather, there is a truly scientific purpose here: Many people wonder if archery hunting is “humane,” and my answer is “Oh. My. Gosh. Yes. It is.” These modern xbows, in particular, terminate deer life with extreme rapidity. The arrows are blowing huge holes through both lungs, and often slicing the heart, as they forcefully smash and cut their way out the other side. By the time the deer knows something just happened to it, it is already dead. Death arrives in about three to five seconds. That is the very definition of “humane.” And I will have to go look for today’s arrow after deer season is over in February. That thing sailed into the next county, such is the power of the Ravin.

Every exit wound from the Ravin xbow looks like this. Total terminal fatality in a few seconds. I have seen high caliber bullet exits causing much less damage than this.

This archery season’s third mature doe. I claim no ownership of this pinpoint accuracy; the Ravin does it all. And the blood trails are quite heavy, from both sides of the animal. Which makes follow-up and game recovery much easier and higher probability.
Our Wildlife Management Comments Submitted to the PA Game Commission
Dear PGC Commissioners,
In so many ways the Game Commission is on an exciting path, really moving forward on policy, staff culture, and scientific wildlife management. It is an exciting time to be a hunter and trapper in the great state of Pennsylvania, thanks to you. Hunting and trapping are supposed to be fun, and the PGC should be able to maximize opportunities without sacrificing the natural resource base. If anything, the agency has been perhaps too conservative, too cautious. In that vein, here are some small suggestions for improving hunting and trapping in Pennsylvania:
a) Make all small game seasons concurrent, start them in late September or early October and run them unbroken until mid February. The current on-again-off-again schedule is silly, an artifact from many decades ago. Our current small game hunting schedule leaves kids and oldsters alike out in the cold with nothing to hunt if they can’t get to deer camp, or if they do kill a deer and want to keep on hunting. Hunters deserve maximum opportunities that do not degrade or put wildlife populations at risk, and adding a few extra days won’t hurt anything, but they will help hunters tremendously. Put another way, the risk of changing this is very low to non–existent, and the benefits are huge. Well, what is the risk, really?
b) Allow the use of snares in rural WMUs and/or on private lands. Cable restraints are an important trapping tool under any circumstances, and especially so as we experience ever-increasing freeze-thaw-freeze-thaw winters, with rain no less. These weird winter conditions render traditional footholds nearly useless both early and late in the season. Cable restraints can function better than footholds under those conditions, but they just are not sufficient for the big coyotes we are encountering. Getting coyotes into cable restraints is tough enough, and holding them there is even tougher. Chew-throughs of our cables are common, where a snare would positively catch the coyote and hold it, bringing it to hand and into the bag. In rural areas (or on private land) there is a far lower expectation or risk of a pet or feral dog or cat being caught. We are ceding too much to the anti-trappers by prohibiting snares where they can do the best good. A pet is an animal that lives in a home. Eliminating a very useful tool because of some vague or low-probability worry is not good policy. We can do better, and snares are much better than cable restraints in general, and particularly in the northern Big Woods areas. Also, CR certification can only be done right in person, through hands-on training. This online certification is going to lead to problems, especially where CRs are used like snares.
c) Allow the use of body-grip (Conibear) traps outside water courses, specifically on running-pole sets for fishers, bobcats, and raccoons. Like the snare situation above, our trapping regulations are unrealistic, they are too conservative, penalizing law-abiding trappers because of vague fears that under reasonable circumstances will not happen. Securing body-grip traps up off the ground is well out of the reach of dogs and domestic cats. Separately, if a pet owner lets their animal out the door to run free, where it can trespass, be hit by a car, be eaten by a coyote or fox or hawk, or get hurt in a fight with another animal, then they do not truly care about it and it is not a real “pet.” Pennsylvania trappers do not deserve to be hurt because of others’ irresponsible behavior. Elsewhere in America, the use of bodygrips on running pole sets is very effective and humane. We can stick with the #160 size as the maximum.
d) Extend the fisher trapping season and areas. Trappers in Berks and Lebanon Counties have told me of catching fishers in their sets, and we are seeing them in Dauphin County. There is no good reason why we cannot extend where and when we trap these abundant predators. Incidentally, they eat bobcats and turkeys, and it would be silly to expect fishers to simply harmoniously co-exist with other animals. They are a voracious predator and they will have a disproportionate impact on predator and prey populations alike if allowed to expand unchecked. Fishers are cool animals and I am all for having them in our ecosystems. What is lacking now are the mountain lions and wolves that in the distant past would have eaten them, and kept them in balance with other wildlife. We humans now fulfill the role of lions and wolves. Let us at ’em.
e) Make sure bobcat populations can sustain these long trapping and hunting seasons. We are seeing a lot less bobcat sign and fewer bobcats on our trail cameras. This was the first year we did not get a bobcat through either trapping or calling in 2G and 4C, and while this may be just our observation, we are concerned. If bobcat harvests must be reduced, then we prefer that it come out of their hunting season. There is a ton of hunting opportunities in Pennsylvania, and not a lot of great trapping opportunities. Heck, muskrats are practically extinct, coyotes have eaten most of the red fox in the southcentral, and possums are clogging nearly every trap. Let us keep our bobcat trapping intact.
f) Reinstate concurrent buck and doe deer hunting. We are seeing a high number of deer nearly every place we hunt (WMUs 2G, 4C, 3A, 5C, 5D). Deer populations are definitely lower than in 2001, and deer are harder to hunt now than then, but the quality is unbelievable, and the herd can sustain both doe and buck hunting. Pennsylvania is now a real trophy destination, so keep up the scientific management, which would include allowing hunting on Christmas Day.
g) Expand the bear season by one day in WMUs 2G and 4C, or rearrange the season entirely. There are an awful lot of bears everywhere, especially in 2G and 4C. On the Friday before bear season starts, we see loads of bears having tea and crumpets in the back yard. They are watching football and hanging out leisurely in reclining chairs. Come Opening Day through Wednesday, we might see the hind end of a bear or two, or we might occasionally harvest a bear, if we work hard enough. By deer season opening day the following week, the bears are back to having tea and crumpets in the back yard, hardly disturbed by all our hunting efforts. Another way to address this is to make bear and deer seasons concurrent, at least for one week, and perhaps start that concurrent season the week of Thanksgiving.
h) Do more to end wildlife feeding. We continue to see mangy bears, and deer baiting under the guise of “helping” wildlife through artificial feeding. It’s not good for the animals, and can actually be bad. People also feed wildlife to entice game animals away from (other) hunters. This is a cultural practice that PGC needs to do more to end, through education and enforcing the bear feeding regulation.
Thank you for considering our comments. We do love the PGC and admire your field staff, especially.
Josh and Isaac First (father and son)
Harrisburg, PA